Tanner Glass seems like a good guy in the locker room but the Rangers' recall of him shows glaring issues in management and idealism.
Earlier today, the New York Rangers have called up grinder/enforcer Tanner Glass from their minor affiliate the Hartford Wolfpack. Tanner Glass has been a part of the Rangers' organization for the last 2.5 years and has had many battles waged over his name. Glass is what the Sportsnet people call, "The Antichrist of Advanced Stats", Tanner Glass is literally one of the worst hockey players over the last half decade regarding advanced stats and the fact that some people value him suggests a divide between the old school hockey style and the ever changing dynamic of the sport. We are no longer in the middle of a paradigm shift, the paradigm shift passed and the people who still cling onto the past, are being weeded out. In a human aspect it's unfair for Glass. His hard work has led him to an NHL career worth 500 games on teams that went pretty far as well. There is something that can be said about that, sure you can argue that many of his former coaches unrightfully gave him spots over younger or faster players during the actual paradigm shift but there are countless other grinders who were just like Glass who never got to the 500 games. He is a well liked guy in the locker room and I think the 500 games for that reason attest to that. Glass has also seen a negative perspective in human interest stories, this is a human being and when the story about how fans turned their backs and shunned him when he was offering to take pics and sign memorabilia was pretty messed up, no player or human deserves that. I hope this little post won't be a direct attack on Tanner Glass, it's not what I want it to be, I just feel that his recent call up provides him to be the medium in which I try to dissect the apparent issue in the Rangers' management and possibly the idealism that surrounds people who may think having a grinder is absolutely necessary.
Let me not create any misunderstanding regarding my stance on the "grinder" in the NHL. I think they are and will be forever valuable. There are grinders who are great at suppressing shots, there are grinders who can hit, be hit and generate possession from their boards work that is extremely helpful for an NHL team. These grinders can come in many shapes and sizes contrary to the belief of some. They can be the Dwight King, Antoine Roussell and Ryan Garbutts of the NHL, they can be the young rookies who can skate trying to make a name for themselves as bottom line players such as the Rangers' Marek Hrivik or they can be guys that simply don't look anything like grinders but their tenacity along the boards leads to possession like Jesper Fast. One thing that separates these players mentioned from Tanner Glass (or Steve Ott who we will get to shortly) is that they have shown that they can provide something to the team in multiple ways and don't simply fire their body into anything that moves.
The Rangers' issues are on defense. It is impossible to deny and earlier in the year I think anyone would be jealous of the Rangers' forward depth except maybe the Penguins. Some people have begun to think that the Rangers are facing another problem and that is the toughness of their forward group. If you don't think so it is understandable if you put yourself in their shoes and put more value in the grinding style. According to most people that I have spoken to that match this person, the Rangers have lacked the ability to win board battles, they have lacked the desire to get to the front of the net and they have the stark inability to protect themselves or their goalie. The Tanner Glass re-addition hopes to quell these issues but I have my serious doubts.
The Rangers really aren't that wimpy of a team. If you're looking at hits, according to the NHL the Rangers have more hits than trademarked hard teams to play against, Columbus Blue Jackets and the Minnesota Wild. They also only have 19 less hits total over the season than the Washington Capitals who will beat the Rangers by toughness and not the fact that they have the best team in the NHL talent-wise. Also let's cut it out, all of these guys are tough, they're in the NHL, if you're going to please like my sport after every injury don't pick and choose when players look tough.
First and foremost, Tanner Glass has had a role on a Rangers roster for essentially a season and three quarters and I would argue that his play at this time didn't suddenly make the Rangers tougher in those areas. Henrik Lundqvist still got bumped, Ryan McDonagh and JT Miller still got crosschecked behind the play, and I didn't do well on my Organic Chemistry exam when he was supposed to provide protection. Tanner Glass only played 12 minutes or more in 9 of his 57 games last season, I struggle to see how those 12 minutes provide toughness for the Rangers for the other 80% of the game. I don't see how Tanner Glass provided the toughness in those scenarios, he got into a handful of fights over the season and some can say one or two of them changed the course of the game because of momentum but there is no way to prove that and even if it did do you really want a human being fighting every single game with the research about concussions becoming public? I will say one thing, Glass tried, he tried to provide the intangibles that some are clamoring about and one thing I respect is that in my recollection he never tried to go after a player in an unfair matter like perhaps some other "grinders" (goons) he played with respect in his game and respect in the fact that he made it, I fully believe this.
Tanner Glass' ability to win board battles is also a bit overstated, When tracking meaningful hits that lead to puck possession, Glass was ranked 7th on the team (SMALL SAMPLE SIZE ALERT ONLY TRACKED 20 GAMES). I also think you can make the comparison between the games that glass played and the 2014 season where our 4th line grinded and cycled the opposition into submission. Dom Moore who was a part of the team from 2014-2016 showed his numbers and possession absolutely tank with Tanner Glass on the ice. For those who get angina from Corsi look away, Dom Moore had a 48% CF without tanner glass, together they were at 42%. That is an absolutely massive drop off. Without Tanner Glass, Dom Moore had a CA/60 of 53.36 with Glass that number spiked to 59.89%. If 60% of the time you're on the ice you have shots being fired at your goalie, that's not good defense. Due to the fact that these players played for a long period of time together, we should also look at goals against, without Glass Moore's GA/60 was 1.92, with 2.21 (All stats from puckalytics.com).
People have told me that the Rangers need players to provide toughness so everyone else can be tough. The old expression in hockey is used (thanks @Whocares2727) "A guy with courage gives 2 inches and 20lbs to every teammate". Look I want to believe it, I really do, I want the Rangers to win net front battles but in my years playing hockey, although we respected the grinders I don't think it is biologically possible to make certain players aggressive in dangerous areas unless the player you acquire has rabies. I just find it really hard to believe that the less than 12 minutes a night Tanner Glass will play will suddenly make the Rangers more aggressive in front of the net and other areas, that wasn't the case for the last 2 years and I struggle to see how that will change this year. My issue with the callup isn't Glass him self per se, but the fact that we had tried Glass out for the same reason the last 2 years and nothing good came of it. I have a gripe against management and coaching staff for this call up for that exact reason. If they felt, and it was well documented that they did, that they needed toughness, a kick in the ass or whatever, then why not make it a thing at trade deadline. I'm fine with adding depth, I think for the right (read cheap) price I would be all for more physical depth over guys like Pirri or Puempel. Glass didn't work out, maybe get somebody else. The Habs are seen by some of the biggest Glass proponents in the NYR fanbase as Satan. They specifically made the toughness additions of Ott, King and Martinsen to beat the Rangers because the Rangers can't handle the toughness. Just so you know, only King here is probably still an NHLer. I would've been indifferent to paying that price for King but for the price they paid the other 2 guys it's certainly laughable. I'm a big believer in developing your own 4th line, no reason to pay either in contracts or picks for players like Ott or Martinsen.
I am pretty angry at the NYR management for this reason, they could've "easily" made moves to try a player that can provide toughness and maybe more. Glass didn't work, his advanced stats blow and I feel he didn't provide THAT much toughness to the Rangers. The Rangers could've made the same trade for King. Another move that the Rangers could've made is target grinders that were sent down due to cap constraints, Ryan Garbutt of the Anaheim Ducks was a main target of mine. Not only is he a tough grinder that is willing to drop the gloves but he is also good on faceoffs (if you're into that fetish). Garbutt would've likely been able to be had for cheap because the Ducks are in not only a cap bind but he was also in the AHL for half the year. To compare Glass and Garbutt analytically, since the start of the 2014-2015 season Garbutt has a lower CA/60 57.11 vs Glass' 61 meaning less shots against. Garbutt has a higher CF% of 50.47% compared to Glass' 42%. Garbutt had a higher xGF% stat of 50.07 compared to Glass' 42.1%. Relative to their teams, Garbutt has a CF% of -.82%. THATS TERRIBLE IM SURE GLASS IS BET... no, Glass during his time with the Rangers has a relCF% of -7.29%. Garbutt however was had a Rel CA/60 of 1.65 showing that he is a pretty good shot suppressor. If there was one thing that Glass did better than Garbutt it's that he didn't take as many penalties but hey why do we care about that if we want toughness amirite.
Point is the Rangers could have if they really felt it was a problem bring players who have had better success than Glass did over the last 2.5 years. The call up also restricts the Rangers or their fans in likely seeing Ryan Graves. The NYR and every NHL team for that matter is given 4 call ups after the deadline. 2 of them were just used on Tanner Glass and Steve Kampfer. Just a reminder, Buchnevich is on an emergency call up so he doesn't even count as a call up that the Rangers will likely have to do sooner rather than later. This gives us 1 call up left for Hrivik who has shown to be a nice boards player in his small sample size, Chris Summers who AV seems to love as his left hand call up, or the NYR's best prospect in the AHL right now, 6'4 Defenseman Ryan Graves. It just seems like poor asset management to me.
No comments:
Post a Comment